VideosSubscribe

Claude vs GPT: Can AI Make a PowerPoint You'd Actually Use?

The sample sheet, the two-step prompt that worked and a template are below, and you can download both finished decks.

The sample spreadsheet

A coffee chain I made up: three stores, July to September, with revenue, orders, categories, the delivery share and a few notes. Use it to try this yourself.

Version one: one sentence

One sentence
Make me a PowerPoint for our Q3 sales report.

Version two: the spreadsheet, still one sentence

With the sheet attached
Make me a Q3 sales report PowerPoint from this spreadsheet.

The prompt that worked: two steps

Step one asks for findings and an outline only. No slides yet:

Step 1 · outline first
Attached is the Q3 sales data for our three Hilltop Coffee stores. I'm presenting it to my boss next Monday and I only get 5 minutes. My boss is busy and only cares about the bottom line and what they need to decide.

Don't make the slides yet. First read the spreadsheet and tell me:
1. The 3 findings most worth presenting, each backed by numbers from the sheet;
2. A 5-minute outline: one sentence per slide saying what the boss should remember from it.

Once the outline is right, step two:

Step 2 · build the deck
The outline works. Go ahead and build the deck:
- Put the conclusion on the first slide; every slide title is a full sentence, and the body is 3 lines max;
- Only use numbers from the spreadsheet, don't make anything up; chart whatever can be charted, using charts I can edit in PowerPoint;
- The last slide lists what my boss needs to decide;
- Write speaker notes for every slide, about 5 minutes when read aloud;
- When you're done, check it yourself for text that overflows, overlaps or is hard to read.

Mia's tips

  • If the decisions come out vague, add: "For each decision, give two options, your recommendation and the reason, using numbers from the sheet."

For your own deck, fill in the brackets:

Template · step 1
Attached is (your data or notes). I'm presenting it to (who) on (when), and I only get (how many) minutes. (Who) mostly cares about (what).

Don't make the slides yet. First read it and tell me:
1. The 3 findings most worth presenting, each backed by numbers from what I sent;
2. A (how many)-minute outline: one sentence per slide saying what (who) should remember from it.

The two final decks

Claude's first slide: Q3 sales grew 10% on last year but stalled against Q2, and delivery fees took the gain
Claude's delivery slide: sales up $3.4k, extra delivery fees up $7.4k
GPT's fixed last slide: two options and a recommendation for each decision

Mia's tips

  • Five slides each, with real PowerPoint charts: right-click one and choose Edit Data. The speaker notes are written too.
  • I used Claude Opus 5.5 and GPT-6 Astra in Codex with reasoning at its highest setting. If the sheet doesn't spell something out, tell it what to assume.

One last question before you present

Before the meeting
One last thing: what are the 3 questions my boss is most likely to ask after this? Give me a one- or two-sentence answer for each.

More videos

All videos →